In modern electrical systems, surge protectors (SPDs) are critical devices for protecting against damage from lightning strikes and switch surges. However, many people are confused by the different types, such as Type 1 and Type 2 surge protection device.
What Is the difference between Type 1 and Type 2 SPD?This article will provide an in-depth comparison of Type 1 surge protection device and Type 2 SPDs to help you understand their differences, application scenarios, and make the right choice.
Surge protectors (SPDs) are the “safety valves” of electrical systems. Type 1 and Type 2 are the two most commonly used SPDs. They each have their own functions and work together to build a complete protection system.
10/350μs waveform (for Type 1 testing): This waveform simulates some of the current characteristics of a direct lightning strike. Its current rise is slow, but its duration is long, carrying approximately 20 times the energy of the 8/20μs waveform, making it extremely destructive.
8/20μs waveform (for Type 2 testing): This waveform simulates induced lightning and switching surges. The current rises quickly, its duration is short, and its energy is relatively small.
Type 1 lightning surge protection device: Installed in the building’s main distribution panel (main incoming line box), located after the electricity meter and before or after the main circuit breaker (depending on product design).
Type 2 SPD: Installed in distribution panels, such as floor distribution boxes or distribution boxes in critical equipment rooms (e.g., data centers, elevator control rooms).
Type 1 SPD: Must be installed at the power inlet of buildings equipped with external lightning protection systems (lightning rods, down conductors). This is a mandatory requirement of international standards (such as IEC 62305) because it effectively handles direct lightning current coupled from the down conductor to the power line.
Type 2 SPD: Not directly mandatory with external lightning protection systems. Type 2 SPDs are required to handle induced surges regardless of whether the building has an external lightning protection system.
Type 1 and Type 2 SPDs need to work together. A certain line distance must be maintained between them (generally recommended to be at least 10 meters), or decoupling devices (such as dedicated reactors) should be used to ensure that, in the event of a surge, the Type 1 SPD trips first to dissipate most of the energy, and then the Type 2 SPD trips to limit the residual voltage to a lower level. If the distance is insufficient, a large surge may bypass the Type 1 and damage the Type 2.
This is a decision-making process to help you make a choice:
Yes: You must install a Type 1 SPD in the main distribution box.
No/Unsure: You can skip Type 1, but installing Type 2 is strongly recommended.
Even without an external lightning protection system, if your building is located in an open area, on a hilltop, or has long overhead power lines, the risk of lightning strikes is high. Installing a Type 1 SPD can provide a higher level of protection.
Scenario A (Standard residential building, no external lightning protection): Installing a Type 2 SPD in the main distribution box provides sufficient protection.
Scenario B (Villa/commercial building with lightning rod): A Type 1 SPD must be installed in the main distribution box, and Type 2 SPDs must be installed in floor distribution boxes or distribution boxes for critical equipment.
Scenario C (Risk compromise): If space or budget is limited, a Type 1+2 combined SPD can be installed in the main distribution box (see FAQ).
No single SPD can perfectly handle all types of surges. The concept of tiered protection is:
Type 1 (Level 1): Intercepts and discharges the vast majority of the enormous energy (e.g., 90%) at the inlet.
Type 2 (Level 2): Further limits the residual surge voltage after the first level, bringing it within the equipment’s safe range.
Type 3 (Fine Protection): Uses surge strips at the equipment end to provide fine protection for the last mile.
This is like a line of defense: the first line weakens the main force, the second line clears the residue, and ensures the safety of the main base (your equipment).
A complete solution is as follows:
Level I: Main Distribution Box → Type 1 SPD
Level II: Floor Distribution Box → Type 2 SPD
Level III: Equipment Front-End (e.g., sockets) → Type 3 SPD (surge power strip)
Can I Install Both Type 1 And Type 2 Single Phase SPD?
Absolutely, and it’s best practice. Type 1 and Type 2 single phase SPDs work together to provide tiered protection from the inlet to the device.
Difference Between Type 1+2 Combined Spd And Installing Them Separately
I Use Surge Strips On My Outlets. Do I Need To Install Type 2 SPD?
Absolutely necessary. Surge power strips (Type 3 SPDs) have limited discharge capabilities; they are designed to absorb very small residual surges at the device end. They cannot withstand major surge energy transmitted from the power line.
Without a Type 2 SPD dissipating energy at the pre-amplifier stage, a larger surge could directly destroy your surge power strip and connected devices. Type 2 SPDs are the mainstay in protecting the entire circuit branch.
Single Phase SPD VS Three phase Type 1 SPD
Single-phase SPDs are used in single-phase power supply systems (one live wire and one neutral wire), while three-phase Type 1 SPDs are used in three-phase power supply systems (three live wires and one neutral wire or three live wires, one neutral wire, and one ground wire), designed to protect all phase wires from massive surge impacts such as direct lightning strikes.
Optimized by Seraphinite Accelerator
